B2B Ecommerce · 5 min read
Shopify vs Magento for B2B: which should you choose?
Shopify vs Magento for B2B: pricing and quotes, ERP integration, customisation, running costs and when each platform fits, from a team that builds on both.

“Shopify vs Magento” is one of the fastest-rising ecommerce searches in the UK this year, and for B2B businesses the question matters more than most. The platform decides how easily you can show each customer their own prices, take repeat orders, handle quotes and stay in step with your ERP.
We build on both. PureNet is a Shopify Plus Partner, and Magium, the PureNet Group’s Magento agency, works on Magento Open Source and Adobe Commerce. So this isn’t a sales pitch for one or the other: it’s how we’d talk it through with a client.
Which Magento are we comparing?
“Magento” now means two things:
- Magento Open Source: the free, self-hosted edition.
- Adobe Commerce: Adobe’s paid edition built on the same code, with more features, including the B2B module, and options for Adobe to host it, among them Adobe Commerce as a Cloud Service (our overview).
Shopify is a hosted platform throughout. For larger B2B businesses the comparison is usually Shopify Plus against Adobe Commerce, and for smaller ones Shopify’s other plans against Magento Open Source.
B2B features: Shopify Plus B2B vs Magento B2B
Both platforms can run a serious B2B store. They get there differently.
Shopify has B2B built in. You set up each trade customer as a company, and give them catalogs with their own fixed prices, volume pricing and quantity rules, while draft orders let your team build orders on a customer’s behalf. Shopify’s B2B features are available on its Basic, Grow, Advanced and Shopify Plus plans, with Plus adding more control, such as assigning catalogs directly to individual company locations. Quotes are usually handled through draft orders or an app.
Adobe Commerce has a deep native B2B module: company accounts with buyer roles and permissions, shared catalogs with per-company pricing, negotiable quotes, quick order by SKU, requisition lists, purchase order approvals and pay on account (a credit line you manage). On Magento Open Source those B2B features aren’t included; they come from extensions or custom development.
In practice:
- If your B2B needs are account pricing, repeat ordering and a clean trade experience, Shopify Plus B2B is often enough, and simpler to run.
- If you need negotiated quotes, approval chains, requisition lists and complex company structures out of the box, Adobe Commerce’s B2B module is hard to beat.
- If your pricing logic is genuinely unusual (contract pricing per SKU per customer, live from the ERP), either can do it, but it becomes an integration project rather than a platform setting. Our B2B ecommerce solutions page covers how we approach that.
Integration with your ERP
For most B2B businesses the ERP is the source of truth: prices, stock, credit limits and order history. Both platforms integrate well; the difference is where the work lives.
Magento gives you full access to the code and database, so integrations can be as deep as you need, at the cost of maintaining them through upgrades. The Duffells store, for example, is a B2B Magento store joined to its Merlin ERP for each customer’s pricing, credit and stock.
Shopify works through its APIs and apps. That keeps the core platform clean and upgrades automatic, but very heavy or real-time integrations need careful design, usually with middleware between Shopify and the ERP.
Either way, the integration is usually the biggest part of a B2B build, so it’s worth scoping first.
Customisation and control
Magento is the more flexible of the two. You own the code, can change almost anything, and can build features no other store has. That freedom is why complex B2B businesses choose it.
Shopify limits how deep you can go into the platform itself, deliberately. In return, Shopify handles hosting, security patching and core upgrades, and most customisation happens in the theme, apps and checkout extensions.
The question to ask isn’t “which is more powerful?” but “how much of our difference lives in the platform, and how much in our products, pricing and service?”
Performance and the front end
Shopify stores are hosted on Shopify’s own infrastructure, so speed largely depends on the theme and apps you add.
Magento’s default front end has a reputation for being heavy. The Hyvä theme changed that: it is much lighter and faster, and since November 2025 the Hyvä Theme has been free and open source. For many Magento stores, a move to Hyvä is a better answer to speed problems than a move of platform.
Total cost of ownership
Comparing licence prices alone is misleading, because the costs sit in different places:
- Shopify: a monthly plan fee (Shopify Plus is priced for larger merchants), apps, and development. Hosting, security and upgrades are included.
- Magento Open Source: no licence fee, but you pay for hosting, security patching, version upgrades and the development time they take.
- Adobe Commerce: a licence based on your business, plus hosting (or Adobe’s cloud), and development.
Over three to five years, the deciding factors are usually how much custom work you need and how much ongoing platform maintenance you want to own. We’d always model both before recommending either.
When each one fits
Shopify Plus tends to fit when:
- you want to spend less time and money running the platform and more on selling;
- your B2B needs are covered by companies, catalogs and account pricing;
- you sell B2B and B2C from one place and want both to feel modern;
- your team wants to make changes without a developer for everything.
Magento or Adobe Commerce tends to fit when:
- your B2B processes are complex: negotiated quotes, approvals, requisition lists, buyer roles;
- you need deep, custom integration with your ERP and other systems;
- you have, or want, the in-house or agency capacity to own the platform;
- you’re already on Magento and the problem is speed or upkeep, which Hyvä and good maintenance can fix without a migration.
Moving from Magento to Shopify
The top search in this area is “Magento to Shopify migration”, and it’s the move we’re asked about most. Done well, it carries over products, customers and order history, keeps your search rankings with redirects from every old address, and reconnects your integrations. The Dice Shop Online moved from Magento to a bespoke Shopify store with more than 15,000 SKUs.
Our Magento to Shopify migration page explains how we do it, and our ecommerce replatforming service covers moves in any direction, including onto Adobe Commerce.
Questions people ask
Is Shopify or Magento better for B2B? Neither, outright. Shopify Plus B2B suits most account-pricing and reorder needs with less upkeep; Adobe Commerce suits complex quoting, approvals and company structures.
Does Magento Open Source have B2B features? Not natively. Adobe’s B2B module is part of Adobe Commerce; on Magento Open Source, B2B features come from extensions or custom work.
Can we keep our search rankings if we move? Yes, if the migration maps every old address to its new page with a permanent redirect and carries over titles, descriptions and content. It’s one of the first things we plan.
If you’re weighing the two, our Shopify Plus, Magento Open Source and Adobe Commerce teams are happy to talk it through.